Sunday, September 19, 2010

Tahleen reviews: "Charles and Emma: The Darwins' Leap of Faith" by Deborah Heiligman


Author: Deborah Heiligman
Publisher: Henry Holt & Co., 2008
Where and why: I saw this on display at my local library. I heard it had won a few awards and was curious about it, so I checked it out.

Rating: ★★★½

Deborah Heiligman takes on the challenge of writing a biography of one of the most famous scientists in history and his beloved wife, for young readers. But this isn't just a cut and dry book about science and religion—it's a love story that succeeded against all odds.

This was a great overview of the Darwins' life together. Emma was a devoted Christian, and Charles was a devoted scientist with serious doubts about God; yet they managed to make it work, so great was their love for each other. We start off with Darwin's famous pros and cons list of marriage, moving on to his first failed engagement, and finally into his marriage with Emma. Heiligman shows her readers why Emma was such a devoted Christian, why Charles couldn't believe like she did, and how they somehow met in the middle. We share their joy in the births of the children and their sorrow during death, up to the end of their own lives.

It is aimed at the young-adult reading level, and the writing was spot-on for that demographic, but I'm just wondering how many sixth-graders are going to want to read an entire 232-page book about Charles and Emma Darwin. It took me a while to get through it, and I'm in my 20s.

I did really enjoy how Heiligman delved into how the Darwins dealt with the fact that their spiritual beliefs differed so greatly, and yet they were so in love for the duration of their lives. It's a beautiful story, really. At the time I read it I could identify with some aspects of it too, and it really put my own situation into perspective.

Heiligman also does a wonderful job at characterizing these historical figures. We see Darwin's brilliance and his humor, his virtues as well as his faults; we see Emma's passion and devotion, her love and loyalty for her family. It's clear she wants her readers to get to know her subjects, instead of just learning about them.

All in all, this was a great biography for younger readers—the only problem was that it dragged a bit in some places for me, and so I immediately thought of how middle schoolers would take to it. Provided they can get through it, they'll certainly learn a lot about the Darwins and what they put themselves up against. I would even recommend this to adults who are interested in learning more about the famous couple.

5 comments :

  1. Great review, and sounds like a facinating book. I tweeted to my following under the hashtag #helpotherbookblogs

    http://www.ManOfLaBook.com

    ReplyDelete
  2. This looks fascinating! Charles Darwin has always intrigued me but I can't say I've ever known too much about his personal life.

    I love hearing about stories where love conquers any sort of religious or cultural differences so this really looks like an incredible read in that aspect as well!

    I think it is strange that the book is so long when it is intended for ya readers--being that it is in fact non-fiction. Does it read like fiction though?

    ReplyDelete
  3. It doesn't really read like fiction, but it's not dry by any means. Parts of it do tend to drag, though. I still enjoyed it very much, it just took me a while to get through. Definitely read it if you're curious about Darwin and his relationship with Emma though—what a lovely story they had! (Yeah, I'll say it again.)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hmm this actually sounds interesting!
    I really like the cover, simple yet telling and creative..

    ReplyDelete

Related Posts with Thumbnails
 
Site Design By Designer Blogs Content © 2012 The Broke and the Bookish. All Rights Reserved