Author: Catherine Fisher
Publisher: Dial, 2010
Where I got it: I borrowed it from the library.
Why I read it: I like reading the new dystopian stuff, and this was new and dystopian. Plus I had the time to read it.
Here, there are two worlds. There is the Outside, where the people are slaves to Protocol—sticking to the technology and practices of an Era of old, of what seem to be Medieval times. And the other is Inside—within the living walls of Incarceron. Incarceron is a prison that lives and thinks, watching the thousands upon thousands of prisoners it traps inside.
One of these prisoners is Finn, a young man who believes he is different—from the Outside. And when he comes across a mysterious Key with the same insignia that's tattooed on his wrist, he is more sure than ever.
Claudia is the daughter of the Warden of Incarceron, due to be married off to the Prince of the realm. But she will do whatever it takes to escape this fate.
When these two characters come together through a variety of unexpected (on their part) occurrences, they try to hatch a plan to help each other get what they want.
I thought this book was okay. It wasn't outstanding, but it wasn't bad. I liked the ideas, the dystopia of Incarceron and Protocol, but I felt there could have been more development on all counts. None of the characters were very relatable/likable, though some were not as bad as others. A lot of them seemed just a little too flat and/or wooden, while Claudia is usually just plain irritating. She's a somewhat strong heroine, but I didn't particularly like her. The really cool thing about this was that Incarceron is a character in itself; the constantly changing, moving, living organism that contains all its prisoners, some of which are created from its own walls.
I did like the (sparse) plot development of Sapphique, a legendary character who was said to have escaped Incarceron, but not much is revealed in this first book. I would have liked to learn more about him.
There weren't many plot twists that I didn't see coming. It was actually pretty predictable to a point, though there were a few exceptions. Some things were definitely left murky, leaving it open for the sequel, Sapphique. Unfortunately, it's not a particularly memorable novel, so if you read it now and wait for the sequel, you might forget certain plot elements, like I probably will. If you like dystopian YA, I'm not going to say it's a must-read, but it's not a complete waste of time either. If you're interested, it's worth picking up so you can come to your own conclusion.
Bummer. This sounds like an interesting premise. I think I'll probably reading some other dystopian novels before I read this one. Any suggestions?ReplyDelete
I quite enjoyed this book, though I'll admit I was SO confused through most of it. I'll definitely still try Sapphique. Great review :)ReplyDelete
Thanks Melissa! I hope it wasn't too harsh, I just didn't feel it. I think I will read the sequel too, I kind of liked where it was heading.ReplyDelete
Jamie, have you read Life As We Knew It by Susan Beth Pfeffer? I really enjoyed that one, it has two "sequels" too. Also check out The Forest of Hands and Teeth, that is so well written, if you can handle zombie books. They're more post-apocalyptic, really. You should also read Gathering Blue by Lois Lowry if you haven't already, it's a companion to The Giver and excellent.
Thanks for the suggestions Tahleen! Looks like I've got some good reading to do seeing that I've never read any of them! The Giver was my favorite book when I was younger..and I never knew there was a companion book!ReplyDelete
"The Giver" is still one of my favorite books. It took me years to realize there was a sequel. I added "Incarceon" to my "to-read" list.ReplyDelete
Aw, sorry you didn't like this one. I really enjoyed it, especially the prison. I do agree that Claudia could be very annoying. The second book was a bit of a let down for me though - not bad but disappointing. I'll second The Forest of Hands and Teeth. That one is great.ReplyDelete
Jamie, there's a sequel that ties them both together, called The Messenger, so when you finish Gathering Blue you'll have to read that one too!ReplyDelete